OUR MENU

Our sourdough bagels are made with freshly-milled flour and whole grains using traditional bagel-making techniques and organic ingredients.

The Bagel Mill Food Menu: Bagels, Spreads, Breakfast Sandwiches, Lunch Sandwiches, Sides, and Add Ons
ORDER PICKUP
ORDER DELIVERY
The Bagel Mill Coffee & Tea Menu: Coffee, Tea, Cold Drinks, Extras, and More

We proudly serve Land and Water Coffee for our signature coffee, cold brew, and espresso drinks.

Land and Water Coffee Logo

STAY UPDATED

Sign up for occasional emails when we have seasonal specials, offers, and events.

We respect your privacy, unsubscribe at any time.

A PETALUMA FAVORITE

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

  • We are open daily from 7:00 AM to 2:00 PM. We are closed on some holidays which will be reflected on our website, Google, and social media.

  • Yes, our bagels are made fresh daily using the highest quality ingredients including our freshly-milled flour and traditional techniques.

  • Our bagels are unique because we mill our whole grains fresh on-site on a stone flour mill. This process preserves all the wheat berry's naturally occurring vitamins and minerals, creating a flavorful and nutritious bagel.

  • We offer gluten-free bagels from Mamamel's Bread in plain, poppy seed, and onion. The freshly-milled flour used in our non-gluten-free, naturally-fermented bagels can also be easier to digest for people with wheat sensitivities.

  • Yes, we proudly serve coffee from Ritual Coffee along with a selection of other drinks including teas, matcha, lemonades, and cold brew.

  • Yes, we offer free WiFi at The Bagel Mill. You can enjoy our delicious bagels and handcrafted drinks while staying connected.

  • The Bagel Mill is located at 212 Western Avenue in the historic downtown Petaluma, California.

    Southbound 101: Take the E. Washington Street exit and turn right. After 1.1 miles, turn left onto Keller Street, and then right onto Western Avenue, we're on the right.

    Northbound 101: Take exit 472B for CA-116 E. Turn right onto Lakeville Street and continue for 0.7 miles. Turn left after Taco Bell onto E. Washington Street, left again onto Keller Street, and then right onto Western Ave, and we're on the right.

  • While we do not have a dedicated parking lot, plenty of free street parking is available. A free parking garage at 114 Keller Street is also available just half a block from our shop.

    Please note that the Petaluma Market parking lot is reserved for Petaluma Market patrons only, and violators may be towed.